PunyComp 2024 - The results are in!

For the first time, we’re throwing a PunyComp. Some quick facts:

Submissions are due on 29 December 2024.

The voting period ends on 19 January 2025.

The theme is announced right away, so authors can start working whenever they want.

Judges are expected to cast their votes after playing a game for one hour. Hopefully this puts the focus more on short games, which can be done with high quality even in the limited time available.

All the details can be found on the competition page:

22 Likes

Gonna be the fool for asking but…

how is it different from the PunyJam?

5 Likes

There’s a lot more time to write a game. For our jams, authors have had 3-4 weeks to produce a game. For this comp, they have 3.5 months.

If this becomes an annual comp, they may have even more time next year.

5 Likes

But otherwise, it’s still the same rules with submitting/voting, right? The only thing that changed was the length between announcing the theme and submission deadline?

1 Like

Not sure what you mean with the same rules. If you mean that anyone can submit a game, and anyone can be a judge, that’s the same as before.

Some rules have been rephrased and expanded, to make them more clear and precise. The voting period is longer. For the comp, it’s explicitly allowed to submit a remake of an older game - this was never the case with the jams. Judges are asked to submit ratings in more categories than one, and we plan for some kind of recognition for the top scoring games in the other categories.

4 Likes

Very good news. Thank you!

2 Likes

The Comp is now open for submissions, until 29 December.

Since the aim is to write a short game, it’s perfectly fine to join and start working on your game now. There’s a friendly Discord community offering support.

2 Likes

PunyComp 2024 is now in its judging stage! Anyone can be a judge. Each judge needs to play at least three of the games. The judges are asked to play each game for one hour before giving off their vote.

These are the games, in alphabetical order:

The Candy Striper of St. Asterix, by ImprovMonster
A Day in the Life, by GrubStudios
Late Night at the Mall, by Johan Berntsson
Mars, 2049 AD, by Fredrik Ramsberg
Thornfell Manor: 1984, by Tijn Kersjes
A Train to Piccadilly, by Marco Innocenti

Henrik Åsman will be handling the voting process. There is a link on the start page of the comp to a form for giving off votes.

Please help us judge the games!

12 Likes

Great news! I like punyinform games a lot, and of course this great comp. This is a properly time to play puny games when the weather freeze the rivers.
This year, becouse of the busy work I have been less resolutive in testing, but I liked so much what I have seen; Good games with great and original histories, puzzles and literature.
Have fun and I wish you the best luck.

So, I understand that this year we have an punycomp instead a punyjam.

  • Jade.
3 Likes

Thanks to the authors and the organizer for this New Year’s gift :christmas_tree::gift:! I won’t play all the games, but I’ve already put a few boxes aside. I will open them one by one.
Happy New Year to everyone! :fireworks:

4 Likes

Ten days left to judge the games. There’s still plenty of time to join in as a judge.

2 Likes

Just checking since I don’t see it mentioned in the rules: can judges rate games that they beta-tested?

There is no rule against it, so feel free.

2 Likes

34 hours to go for judging games. We’d love to have some more judges!

2 Likes

I played a few of the entries after seeing them also entered into the Short Games Showcase, and they were pretty great. If anyone’s looking for something to play this weekend, I think these are worth checking out!

3 Likes

Since we didn’t specify the timezone for the voting period on the comp page, we’ve decided to extend the voting period until the 19th has ended in all timezones, i.e. at 11:00 UTC on 20 January.

1 Like

The results are in!

The winner of PunyComp 2024 is The Candy Striper of St. Asterix, by improvmonster / Charles Moore, Jr.

It was really close at the top, with two games tied for second place: A Train to Piccadilly, by Marco Innocenti and Thornfell Manor: 1984, byt tkers / Tijn Kersjes.

We also collected ratings for writing and puzzles. A Train to Piccadilly was #1 in the ratings for writing, while The Candy Striper of St. Asterix was #1 in the ratings for puzzles.

Game Author Overall rating # Writing # Puzzles
1. The Candy Striper of St. Asterix improvmonster 7.67 2 1
2. A Train to Piccadilly Marco Innocenti 7.50 1 2
2. Thornfell Manor: 1984 tkers 7.50 5 3
4. Late Night at the Mall johanberntsson 7.18 3 4
5. Mars, 2049 AD fredrikr 6.67 4 5
6. A Day in the Life - A Puny Inform Game Grub Studios 4.20 6 6

Thanks to all who participated as authors and judges!

12 Likes

Congratulations to the contestants! To those who didn’t have the opportunity or time to participate as a judge, all these games are well worth your attention. My reviews will be going up on IFDB presently, likely with solutions for those games that didn’t ship with them.

4 Likes

Congrats to all who participated and specially to the winner
Thanks to the organizers, authors and judges!

3 Likes