Here’s how I decide what level of simulation to implement: I JUST DO WHATEVER I WANT.
Section 1 - Thirst
Lane has a number called thirst. The thirst of Lane is 10.
Every turn while the player is Lane:
If the thirst of Lane is greater than 0:
decrement the thirst of Lane;
if the thirst of Lane is 0:
say "[one of]You're already thirsty again[or]Gosh, you're thirsty[or]You smack your lips. You are thirsty[or]Good grief, it is hotter than heck. And you are thirster than heck.[paragraph break]No, [italic type]thirstier[roman type][as decreasingly likely outcomes].";
If you scroll all the way to the end of that line, there’s a joke where the narrator accidentally says “thirster” instead of “thirstier.” What a strange joke! Huh!
Section 2 - Water Bottle
Lane carries the water bottle.
The water bottle has a number called fullness. The fullness of the water bottle is 0.
Instead of giving the water bottle to Nathalie:
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
run a conversation from Nat4;
otherwise:
say "There's still some water in that bottle! Finish it off before you ask Nathalie for another one."
“Running a conversation from Nat4” involves changing the fullness of the water bottle to the maximum of 10, but the text says that she’s giving you an entirely new bottle.
Here we have a bunch of rules that prevent the water bottle from leaving your inventory. This just simplifies things for me so I don’t have to like, write a conversation where you ask for a new water bottle and Nathalie asks “what happened to the one you had?” or something like that.
Instead of dropping the water bottle, say "[if the fullness of the water bottle is 0]You're supposed to give Nathalie your empty bottles[otherwise]This water is the only thing keeping you going. It would be madness to leave it here[end if]."
Instead of inserting the water bottle into something, try dropping the water bottle.
Instead of putting the water bottle on something, try dropping the water bottle.
Instead of examining the water bottle:
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "Your water bottle is empty. It's not a good feeling.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 3:
say "Your bottle is almost empty. Hopefully Nathalie will give you a full one.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 10:
say "There's still plenty of water left in your bottle. For now.";
otherwise:
say "A full water bottle is a welcome sight, but only because you plan to make it stop being full."
Okay, so, here we’re going to see that “OPEN WATER BOTTLE” and “DRINK WATER BOTTLE” are two different routines, and I don’t know why that is, so let’s see if we can figure it out together.
There’s some randomness to how much water you drink with a given drinking-attempt. I think I started out by writing a bunch of random drinking messages—“you gulp down a bunch of water,” “you take a little sip,” etc—but I realized this would create weird situations if little sips and big gulps emptied the bottle at the same rate. So the text is tied to how much water gets drunk, and it’s impossible to take a big gulp when there’s only a little sip left.
Instead of opening the water bottle:
if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 2 and a random chance of 1 in 3 succeeds:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 3;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 6;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You open up your water bottle and take one last long gulp. Now it's empty.";
otherwise:
say "You open the bottle. You raise the bottle to your lips and, forgetting yourself for a moment, you chug down an unladylike gulp.[paragraph break]But it's so satisfying.[paragraph break]You put the lid back on the bottle.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 1 and a random chance of 1 in 2 succeeds:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 2;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 4;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You open your bottle and take another drink. Now it's empty.";
otherwise:
say "You open your bottle and take a drink. The water doesn't stay cold for long, but it's refreshing nonetheless.[paragraph break]You screw the lid back on.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 1;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 2;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0: [yeah, uh, this can't happen]
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You open your water bottle and drink down the last mouthful. Delicious.";
otherwise:
say "You open your water bottle and take a meek little sip. Then you screw the lid back on.";
otherwise:
say "The bottle feels too light as you reach for the lid.[paragraph break]Oh, it's empty. That's no good."
Instead of closing the water bottle, say "You always leave the lid on, to avoid the risk of spilling."
OH, I get it now! See, the “DRINK WATER BOTTLE” logic below is exactly the same as the “OPEN WATER BOTTLE” logic above, but the text is different:
Instead of drinking the water bottle:
if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 2 and a random chance of 1 in 3 succeeds:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 3;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 6;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You take one last long gulp from your water bottle. Now it's empty.";
otherwise:
say "You raise the bottle to your lips and, forgetting yourself for a moment, you chug down an unladylike gulp.[paragraph break]But it's so satisfying.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 1 and a random chance of 1 in 2 succeeds:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 2;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 4;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You take another drink, emptying your water bottle.";
otherwise:
say "You take a drink from your water bottle. The water doesn't stay cold for long, but it's refreshing nonetheless.";
otherwise if the fullness of the water bottle is greater than 0:
now the fullness of the water bottle is the fullness of the water bottle minus 1;
now the thirst of Lane is the thirst of Lane plus 2;
if the fullness of the water bottle is less than 0: [yeah, uh, this can't happen]
now the fullness of the water bottle is 0;
if the fullness of the water bottle is 0:
say "You drink down the last mouthful from your water bottle.";
otherwise:
say "You take a meek little sip from your water bottle.";
otherwise:
say "The bottle feels too light.[paragraph break]Oh, it's empty. That's no good."
If you type in “DRINK WATER BOTTLE” then the narration doesn’t mention anything about messing with the lid of the bottle. If you type in “OPEN WATER BOTTLE” then the narration says stuff like “You open the bottle and drink…” to respect the player’s literal input as well as the player’s implied intention. The fiddliness of bottlecaps did not appeal to me (even if the fiddliness of sip-volume obviously did) but I didn’t want to respond to “OPEN WATER BOTTLE” with something like “Hey don’t worry about opening it, just drink the water” when I could save the player some time.
A Rope of Chalk is in many ways a game about drinking water, so it made sense to implement the drinking of water in this much detail, although it has no practical effect beyond staving off messages about how thirsty you are. But a system like this would not be out of place in any game about being outside on a hot day, even one in which the elemental power of water is not a vital thematic concern.