I’ll edit as I find more.
Review-as-poetry thread
Reviews on IFDB
Leigh Alexander (The Guardian)
Antimony
Sam Kabo Ashwell
ata
Monsieur Bouc
Cerxi
Wade Clarke
Alan DeNiro
George Dorn
Jason Dyer
Elizabeth
Liz England
evouga
French IF forum
Joseph Geipel
JoshuaH (as a game)
Healy
Christopher Huang
ifwizz.de (German-language reviews)
Marco Innocenti
Joey Jones
Khalisar
Kivie
Jason Lautzenheiser
Loki
loopernow
Herr M
Magicswordsman
Michael Martin
M.E. Miller
miscellaneous intfiction reviews
Katherine Morayati
Marius Muller (twitter)
Mark Musante (twitter)
Octopus Overlords
Michael Wayne Phipps Jr.
Tracy Poff
Jenni Polodna
PaulS
Emily Short
The Rest of Your Mice
A Tonne Of Feathers
Jake Wildstrom
Caleb Wilson
The Xenographer
Reiko Yukawa