Iron ChIF: Season One Episode 4 (Audience Commentary)

Ladies and gentlemen, prepare yourselves: You, too, are part of the show!

This thread is for audience commentary on the fourth episode of Season One for Iron ChIF. If you’d like to cheer, crack jokes, make observations or ask questions, please do – that’s what this thread is for! Your questions and comments will be brought to the attention of the episode’s cast.

Keep an eye out for these key dates:

  • Sun Nov 15 – development period begins
  • Fri Nov 20 – development period ends, finished games released for play
  • Sun Nov 22 – judges’ scoring announced, audience voting begins
  • Tue Nov 24 – audience voting ends, winner declared

Remember: For Iron ChIF your votes will determine which competing chef prevails. The judges’ scoring reflects their combined expert opinion, but it will be used to determine the winner only in the event that the audience vote yields a tie.

Those of you who are official Tasters are encouraged to put on your Taster flair to show support for the chefs who are putting themselves through the wringer for your entertainment and edification. If you’re not yet an official Taster, you can sign up at any time via the group page.

We hope that you enjoy the show!

7 Likes

In case you missed it, I’m going to be running the first edition of the Iron ChIF Home Cooking Jam concurrently with the end of this episode: Iron ChIF Home Cooking Jam #1.

You can enter it at any time until the end of its development period, but if the idea interests you at all, you can weigh in on a current rules question over on this thread.

9 Likes

Wow, I just read the interview with the challenger Vyner Vanderhumeken. I can’t believe people still remember Jacek Pudlo. I’m not sure why, but something about VV’s mix of strongly-held opinions and humility appeals to me. I’m looking forward to his performance in this contest.

3 Likes

With no parser, I’m expecting it to be the differentest match to date, but we’ll see.

-Wade

2 Likes

At last, the contest will embrace modern IF :stuck_out_tongue:

Next one will be QBN based (unless this one is)

5 Likes

I am so impressed with this panel of judges. I’ve really loved works by each of them. They really know their stuff. This might be my favorite Iron ChIF yet!

1 Like

I’m waiting for the ingredients, esp. the rejected pair (but NO, rpt, NO promises !!)

Best regards from Italy,
dott. Piergiorgio.

2 Likes

I would be horrified if someone could make a functional, engaging QBN in a week. Which of course means we need a future episode using some QBN-specific tool!

5 Likes

I would think it’s about the same level of managing-your-possibility-space problem as making a parser game in a week? Just one that less people have experience with. Given that I have combat mechanics on the brain right now, I was actually thinking that depending on the challenge ingredient, I might spend the next 5 days playing along privately at home, as a conveniently time-boxed experiment? Hmm… maybe some kind of fantasy sportsball story? Capture the Flagon? :upside_down_face:

3 Likes

I was unfamiliar with the term QBN before today (of course I have played games like that, I just didn’t know they had this acronym)

So naturally I’m inclined to try one in the home cooking competition, where there is no better way to learn a new form than through a speed if comp, right?

3 Likes

For those participating in Home Cooking Edition, FYI I’ll be announcing the skipped challenge ingredient candidates here shortly after the start of the development period.

1 Like

I think it could be done. Much of the work I’ve put into my storylet-based NeoTwiney games has been the art, if you didn’t insist on them looking like that, I think you could put them together quite quickly.

Of course, engaging is a different question :smiley: But I have confidence in our contestants

1 Like

Is someone going to tell me what a QBN is? Don’t make me and everyone else in the same position as me have to research it themselves!

-Wade

2 Likes

To quote Emily Short from 2016:

Quality-based narrative is the term invented by Failbetter Games to refer to interactive narratives structured around storylets unlocked by qualities. A storylet is typically a paragraph or two of text followed by a choice for the user (each option is referred to as a branch in Failbetter parlance) and text describing the outcome of that choice. Qualities are numerical variables that can go up or down during play, and represent absolutely everything from inventory (how many bottles of laudanum are you carrying?) to skills (what is your Dangerous skill level?) to story progress (how far have you gotten in your relationship to your Aunt?).

For more, see her series of posts wrapping from 2019 into 2020:

Or perhaps this long January 2020 talk for the London IF Meetup which includes an audience exercise at the end by way of example.

QBN/storylets is usually associated with large complex games but you can also use them to duplicate more traditional IF structures, perhaps with more player flexibility in the order the story plays out; perhaps something like multiple NPC stories that you might uncover in interleaving fashions (like you might talk to different NPCs in different orders in a parser game). There have been a few smaller stories: Autumn Chen has a few, e.g. Lilac Song is about 3k words. Ian Michael Waddell’s Laika, which I commissioned for my old Twine library, is about 11k words. Emily Short’s Restless (hrm, which seems to have been taken down a couple years ago) was about 16-17k words and was written in one major binge, IIRC. Hituro probably has a couple as well?

6 Likes

I do. A lot of my recent games have very open structures and are controlled by storylets under the surface. A Mouse Speaks to Death is probably the most obvious of these, but Zenith and Mouse Train: Overland are constructed the same way, as big pools of self-assembling content.

I’m quite fascinated by games that can be replayed with variety, so I often use storylets as a form of procedural generation, with varying factors (narrative qualities in Mouse speaks to Death, inventory in Zenith, etc. ) guiding the selection as you play rather than in advance.

I’ve gotten to the point where adding MQBN to a new Twine project is almost a given, since I’ll likely find a use for it somewhere even if only for random events or as a conversation topic manager.

1 Like

Thanks much. Yeah, I’ve read all the storylet stuff over time. So ‘Quality’ means a variable when we’re not using Failbetter’s parlance.

-Wade

1 Like

Yep. Writers like coming up with imaginative names for things, go figure.


Anyway… mirrors that reflect alternate universes. My first thought is “can you move objects through them, or only see things?” And if you can’t affect things in the other universe (and vice versa), what kinds of cool things can you still do with that?

Yeah, that naming choice gave me a smirk also. I imagine it had a double meaning when Failbetter coined it.

The first example that came to my mind was “Final Girl” by @HanonO , a game which sucked me into playing “Fallen London” for a few months. Regrettably both games were written in Storynexus, so they are no longer supported.

@severedhand I saw you wrote a thoughtful review of “Final Girl” on IFDB, so you were probably with me voting on the high side of the median which helped “Final Girl” win “Golden Banana of Discord” in 2013.

When I started researching QBN add-ons for Twine (just yesterday) I was thinking about it as a system for literal card-deck mechanics (like “Fallen London”) but I then realized QBN can be used to even greater effect when those mechanics are hidden below the surface.

Edit: I should probably bring this back on topic re:“Audience Commentary”: I loved OtisDog’s introduction to the challenge ingredient (Mirrors that reflect alternate universes). That introduction contains so many thought provoking literary allusions, from modern to ancient times. I also appreciated Mathbrush’s shout-out to Zelda “Link to the Past” which is my favorite Nintendo game ever. In “Link to the Past” the movement between universes is executed with a literal mirror object, but alternate universes abound in all the most successful games of the Zelda series: big world vs small world, past vs present, seasons of the year, human perception/animal perception; mirror universes are a great starting place for puzzle design.

4 Likes

OK, Home Cookers, these were the challenge ingredients passed over for this episode:

someone on a manned space mission learns that war has broken out

and

a psychoscope, which is like a stethoscope but it allows one to hear thoughts

Have at them!

9 Likes

I’m looking at these difficult ingredient, interesting challenges, but is OT here (but I note that the selected ingredient will be unfair for everyone else, having already a mirror reflecting an alternate universe around… :wink: )

But, back into IT, what is interesting and promising is svlin’s considerations on CSS, which in the contest of an universe and its mirror allows the use of different palettes for the two universes.
Which is a taste I really like, no doubt.

Best regards from Italy,
dott. Piergiorgio.

3 Likes