Labelling is a thing, especially with food and clothes.
Examples:
I’m thinking of incorperating a phrase in tools and potential future games I write that indicate that no AI was used in the writing process (not excluding secondary tools, like the compiler).
Draft: “Made by humans for humans.”
Any other suggestions?
The logo could be the outlines of a human skull/head (seen from the side) with the brain in it.
Your slogan seems optimal to me.
This has been the tagline of my system in development for some years:
A full-featured, open-source, interactive fiction engine made in vanilla javascript, by humans for humans.
I like it. There’s a “no generative AI” tag at IFDB, but this sounds better.
I’ll gladly add it to my software suite that I released today.
Do you mean “not including secondary tools like the compiler”? That part may be harder to track—I can currently say with some confidence that the Dialog compiler has no AI-generated code in it, because the only changes to the compiler inner workings have come from me and Susan Davis, and I believe neither of us uses LLMs to code. And I can say with some confidence that the ZIL compiler does, because Tara McGrew has been very open about her LLM use. But it’s not hard to imagine an alternative world where other people submit LLM-generated pull requests to Dialog and Tara doesn’t discuss LLM use openly on this forum.
Regardless, I wouldn’t mind a label like this, especially if someone artistically inclined were to design something cool for it. I’m not a purist about avoiding games with LLM-generated code, but I don’t intend to use it myself, so if other people do care then I won’t pass up the opportunity to pat myself on the back a bit.
“No em dashes were harmed in the making of this product.” 
“Certified Organic” or “Human Made” is what I would go with.
I prefer slogans of what a thing is, not what it isn’t. So saying “AI-free” means less to me than “Human Made”, for example.
That’s a hot take. The thing no one is talking about. The uncomfortable truth. 
Yes.
I couldn’t really know what a compiler, for example, used when it was developed. I can only be sure what I, myself have added.
My thinking also. I don’t wan’t to be negative, only state the positive.
Plus, it ages well.
What do you think about writing both: “Made by humans for humans. AI-free” ?
Products made with AI assistance still have human authors.
This seems like it would mean different things to different people. What would most people want it to signify?
Actually, maybe a poll would help:
You’re such a buzzkill, Phil.
The question of what human made means reminds me of a puzzle maker who uses hand and power tools to shape masters either from scratch or by modifying parts from mass produced puzzles and then making molds and casting resin copies of those masters as needed claiming designers who use CAD software to design puzzles and 3-D print those designs didn’t actually make the resulting puzzle.
Manmade for Mankind
Made by Flesh
Crafted with Hands
Truly Handmade
Only Blood Here
I think @prevtenet makes a great point here.
If we are talking about interactive fiction stories/games, what I care about the most is that the narrative content I am reading is written by a human being.
If the compiler and/or programming language under which a human made story has been developed was co-authored by an LLM… so what?
I feel like if you want the whole toolchain to be AI-free, It’s much more about you making a statement and expressing a strong opinion about AI in general. Which is fine, everyone has their rights to their views and beliefs, but I feel this goes beyond what such a “seal” should be about.
LLMs, in particular Anthropic’s Mythos model family, is currently significantly revolutionizing the life sciences industry, from the discovery of new medicine to cancer research and rare diseases. I doubt anyone would reject a cure for cancer just because it was co-developed with an LLM.
Henrik’s stated goals seem pretty unambiguous. Perhaps it would be appropriate to create a new thread about the revolutionary properties of LLM, if that’s a desirable discussion to have. If we don’t have such a thread already, that is. I have the AI tag muted.
