IF Derby
IF Derby is a gamble. You’re gambling, sure, but the game itself is also a gamble. It’s a bet that you the player will invest enough time and attention into what appears to be a purely random dice roll that eventually you’ll see there’s more to the game than you thought. Reading the reviews, it is clear that some players did and some players did not. I initially did not. That is partly my own fault: I was playing IF Derby after some emotionally exhausting days (including an evening of serious worry about the safety of a friend’s child), and I don’t expect I was in the most patient or attentive mood. In retrospect, perhaps I should have played a game or read a book I already knew. But I don’t think IF Derby goes free! I’m still not entirely certain of what triggers the hidden content, but I think it is betting on a losing IF Derby without thereby losing all your money. Since I was betting my entire $500 every time, this was never triggered. Even after somebody told me what I had to do, I played two full games where I lost my entire starting capital in $50 bets without IF Derby appearing among the contenders. So I suppose the stars have to align just right – both in terms of the strategy you choose and in terms of the random number generator – before you can move to the intended play experience.
Once we reach the end screen, we are treated to a reflection on IF Comp. The main ideas seem to be that the competitive nature of IF Comp can lead to (1) endlessly thinking that your game isn’t good enough for the competition yet; (2) being disappointed when a game you put a lot of love in doesn’t do well in the competition; and then (3) maybe a complaint that it is already clear in advance who is going to win, and that this is a reason to leave IF Comp aside and go somewhere else (but I’m not certain that that is the intended reading).
None of this is false. At the same time, IF Comp is also an environment where you get to have people pay attention to your game and give serious critical readings / advice, boons that have little to do with the grading and that are not at all present in a race of the IF Derby type. Even when we look solely at the competitive aspect, pretty weird and unexpected stuff has managed to do well in the past. Insofar as the point of IF Derby is that we shouldn’t think about the competition as a horse race, it’s easy to agree. If the game wants to criticise the community for making it too much about the horse race – and I’m not sure that it wants to – I wonder whether the criticism is fair. Thinking about the issue did give me a new appreciation of the fact that Spring Thing has consciously chosen to drop the competition aspect. There are both games and people for whom that simply works better.
In 2019, my game Turandot came 2nd place in IF Comp. That was great! It was, also, of course, just short of ending in 1st place. I can’t say I was immune to the ambivalent feelings this engendered. The worst is when something in your mind starts becoming extra critical of the work that placed above yours; thoughts pop up that suggest is has been over-rated, that it wasn’t really better than yours. That is something that competition does to you, or at least it can do it to me, and it takes real work to counteract it. You’ve got to overcome these thoughts. That work is worth doing. Overcoming your own resentful reflexes, especially in a low-stakes setting like IF Comp, can only help you become a better, more magnanimous person. Still, it is possible that I myself would also flourish more – or certainly not less – in a less competitive setting, and that for me IF Comp would be even better with less Comp.
Does IF Derby leave me rich? That what it says on the end screen! YOU ARE RICH! Well, I’m a little bit richer in insights, and perhaps just a tiny little bit richer in magnanimity. More importantly, my delicious IF friends, the child turned out to be safe. Who, after all, could give the slightest damn about crap like getting 1st place in IF Comp?