Rabbit's IFComp 2026 Reviews

The Copper Tavern (Alexander)

Played on: 21st September
How I played it: Downloaded and ran on Windows Frotz
How long I spent: 27mins (15mins to win, 12mins to noodle around afterwards)

Puzzle and endgame spoilers here, but it’s only a 10-15 minute game - if I avoided all spoilers, there wouldn’t be much to talk about.

I’ve been trying not to just copy-paste passages from games to mark them up for errors, because if I’m not careful I can stray into being mean rather than constructive. However, this time I’m going to indulge, as there are a few issues with The Copper Tavern which are both glaring and, forgive me for saying so, quite funny. Sorry if I stray too far into mockery, as I think this may be a first project from a new author and I don’t want to discourage them, but this is one of those cases that really demonstrates the importance of asking someone else to proofread or test.

For example, here’s the first impression The Copper Tavern makes:

THE TAVERN HEIST
An Interactive Adventure based on handwritten notes.
Release 1 / Serial number 260828 / Inform v6.45 PunyInform v6.7 R

Old Dirt Road
An old dirt road stretches out before you with a dense set of trees on either side, only allowing a few rays of light from the setting sun to escape the thick canopy of cottonwood and maple. Just off the path sits a cozy little tavern with warm light glowing from its windows.

> x tavern
You can’t see any such thing.

So we have the title changing between the ballot and the gamefile (I’ll stick with The Copper Tavern), and then a failure to implement the object which the game is named after, whichever title you use. From here on, The Copper Tavern is fighting an uphill battle to keep you engaged on its own merits; it’s beefed it obviously and immediately and now part of you is waiting for the next mistake rather than engaging with the world.

To give it its due properly, this is a tiny parser game that drops you next to a tavern holding an AK-47 (you, not the tavern). It’s not clear what your goal is initially, but after poking around you’ll learn that the tavern needs to raise 1000 gold pieces or face eviction. So we end up on a little six-room quest to save this cosy little drinking hole. This feels like a snippet of a Zork game, which I mean as a compliment – it has that screwball-fantasy vibe, where it could be a Dungeons and Dragons scenario if it wasn’t for the vending machines, or in this case, the assault rifle.

The blurb implies a choice of stealth gameplay or guns blazing. That’s technically true, but it’s not as detailed as you might expect. There’s a locked door which you can shoot the lock off, or you can use the lockpick you were given at the start of the game instead. As far as I can tell, that’s it. I’m open to the idea that I’m missing some deeper secret (I usually do), but I don’t think the lockpick is necessary anywhere, and the AK-47 hardly has any other uses; the player character will refuse to shoot most things, apart from the hapless tavernkeep, who you can cheerfully blast in the leg over and over again.

Speaking of which, that’s really where things start to go wrong for The Copper Tavern. Having worked out that you can go >in to enter the unimplemented tavern (fair enough, makes sense, but I’d still like exits to be listed somehow), you have a go at talking to the tavernkeep:

> talk to tavernkeep
“Cheers mate! Feel free to ask me about the tavern, the beer, the king, the debt, the eviction notice, or that casino in the back.”

> ask tavernkeep about tavern
“Sorry mate, can’t help you with that. But ask me about the king, the debt, the casino, the eviction, or beer!”

> ask tavernkeep about eviction
“So you heard of the eviction? Well, the king says if I don’t pay a thousand gold by the next moon, he’ll tell his men to tear this place down! I don’t know what I’m going to do, I don’t have nearly enough to pay them what I owe!”

The issue is not the fact that the tavernkeep volunteers the tavern as a topic and then immediately denies all knowledge. It’s not that he offers the eviction as a topic and then wonders how you know he’s being evicted. (Although those are both a little funny.) It’s that he offers the eviction as a topic at all, because this completely cuts out half of the puzzles in the game, where you find a way to sneak upstairs and then crack his safe to find the eviction notice. It’s clearly expected that you should have done this by the end, as there’s a little gag that assumes you’re holding the notice, but the tavernkeep here gives away the knowledge that you’re supposed to acquire by investigation. It’s a shame, too, because that safecracking puzzle is funny in an intentional way - it’s a shitpost of a puzzle which lasts just long enough to finish just before it gets annoying.

There are other issues too, but I’m concerned the above is already too harsh, so I’ll end it here. I think I’ve illustrated the fundamental issue that The Copper Tavern needed a lot more testing. I assume it didn’t have any testers as I can’t find any credits. Making a text adventure is very difficult, and goodness knows I’ve made some blunders in my text adventures, but I think a little game like this needs more care and attention to detail than you might realise, otherwise the bugs and the errors completely subsume the actual good work you’ve done.

11 Likes