baezil's IF comp '26 reviews (latest: Ḫattušumna Laḫḫa)

Quackpond, by Quackpond Admins

Travel back with me to the relatively early internet. I’m 14. I spend my daily allotted hour of dial-up internet time split between Runescape and a Lord of the Rings-themed geocities message board built by a friend. There are maybe seven members (it’s invite-only); we use it to write nerdy roleplays, none of which we finish, and discuss the books/movies on which those nerdy Rps are based. At the time I’m horribly in love with the friend who made the site (I’ll be in love with them for another couple years; I’ll never do a thing about it). Meanwhile, one of the other members apparently has a crush on me, starts causing drama with the site creator in some kind of misguided rivalry. Parents get involved, it’s all weird and embarrassing, friendships end, and our little geocities site, like Middle Earth in the third age, enters its sad decline. This happened a thousand times, in a thousand different ways.

I really enjoyed Quackpond. It’s such an effective speedrun of this quintessential early 'net experience. The fact that you play as someone peripheral to the core relationships is so smart; most of the time, you were a bystander to this sort of thing, only realizing way too late how serious and messy and totally out of your hands the whole thing was. This is an experience that even younger folks will recognize; how many Discord servers have died this death? The difference is that back in my early teens, that there was no discord; these small communities had to be built, and a lot of us didn’t know how to do that. You relied on people who could code, or who knew html, and though friendships sometimes survived on larger forums or various IM services, most of the time these sites were like deep sea vents. When they went dark, the communities that had clustered around them just died out. We talk a lot these days about the internet being so corpo, and it’s true, but any ownership of the early web required skills that not everyone had. Enshittification still happened, in a way, but instead of ads it was immaturity, jealousy, resentment, poorly handled feelings or neurodivergence that made a site unusable. As soon as I saw the post about the site shuttered I had just enough time to go look at my duck (Doodle, a grey muscovy) one last time; I tried to play with him, got that final error. Ouch.

I love the way this game works. The gameplay is slight, but it works well, never overstays its welcome. I overuse “well calibrated” as a descriptor of small games, but this one is well calibrated, the perfect length to say what it’s saying, just enough variation in what your clicking on to hide the fact that you are just clicking on links. Writing and design are great, it was funny (there was always a duck song guy; the geocities creator’s brother was a duck song guy, actually, by which I mean he incessantly referenced that specific duck song), it made me genuinely sad. Great stuff!

The Chart

Interaction — You can play with or feed your duck, though I don’t think those numbers can actually hit 0, and you can add persistent text posts to the forum threads and determine the tone of the responses. What you write doesn’t matter, so you can break the illusion if you want, and there’s only one ending that you can’t change. Interaction is fairly low overall, though it feels more substantial if you lean into the role.

Fiction — The story is the experience here. This work doesn’t exist without the narrative, so I’m cranking that fiction dial all the way up.

Game - Your duck’s meters can’t hit zero (EDIT:I tried a “no playing with the duck” run and didnt hit 0, but I think you CAN hit 0 by visiting the duck page, neither feeding nor playing w duck, and then going back to the forum. Will investigate more tomorrow.), and the ending isn’t affected by your choices. You don’t really have a goal beyond “experience the story,” so game is cranked down to 0.

*mandatory disclaimer: chart doesn’t measure quality, just the degree to which each element is present

11 Likes