Thanks for the replies. I’ve realized that I shouldn’t focus on it too much, and there’ll always be people who disagree with me or my comments. It’s not worth worrying about, and a lot of my reviews get more positive responses than negative, so I want to keep writing them.
And yeah, comments would be a nice feature. Noticing the controversial aspect of the game kind of deterred me from playing any more, since it wasn’t in the description anywhere and I wanted potential players to be aware. The best way to do that just seemed to be an unstarred review, and the IFDB guidelines even mention you can do this if you haven’t gotten far enough into the game to form a full rating.